New “Karate Kid” still contains insidious stereotypes
The new “Karate Kid” with Jackie Chan and Jaden Smith has supposedly learned from the past, setting out to poke holes in some stereotypes about Asians.
That’s good news for any Asian middle-schooler tormented by the “Wax on, wax off” catchphrase of the original.
The film parodies the idea that all Asians are foreigners (“Dude, I’m from Detroit”) and can grab flies out of the air with chopsticks.
It also preserves some of the positives from the original. The heart-warming, cross-racial coalition is still there, as is the theme of reciprocal redemption, to say nothing of the obligatory training montage.
But what’s also still there is a tired image that always surrounds Hollywood fantasies about Asians: We respect our elders; we obey authority; we are preternaturally focused and preternaturally cruel; we have bad hair.
In recasting the film’s protagonist as black, “The Karate Kid” echoes last year’s much-hyped films, “Precious” and “The Blind Side,” in its implicit message that black people can’t save themselves, but need to be saved by others.
And in this case, who better than us Chinese?
That’s right, we’re the ones with self-discipline. And our snake-fighting skills? Off the hook.
Or so, once again, Hollywood would have us believe.
The original “Karate Kid” gets credit for linking sensei Miyagi’s social withdrawal and curmudgeonly attitude to racial trauma: the death of his family enmeshed within the paradox of Japanese-American internment (the original racial profiling) while members of the much-decorated 442nd served their country during World War II.
The shift of location to China gives us nice shots of the Forbidden City and the Great Wall, but waters down Mr. Han’s backstory, replacing the original’s hidden American trauma with relatively generic survivor’s guilt.
More insidious is the veiled economic message of the new “Karate Kid”: Job losses in Detroit are somehow due to labor outsourcing to China, a nation of dress-alike, go-along bullies. Next thing you know, we’ll all have to move to China.
If Jackie Chan is miscast as a melancholic Mr. Han here, at least he’s not performing the gross racial stereotype. As the New York Times’ Lawrence Downes noted in an obituary about the mixed legacy of character actor Pat Morita, who played Mr. Miyagi in the original “Karate Kid”: “But still, it bother me Miyagi-san so wise, but find it hard use articles, pronouns when talk.”
Dude, that how we talk. You no like, you go live Arizona.
The Asian version of a minstrel show would look like this: lots of butt kicking, Zen cool and total concentration. I guess everybody loves kung fu.
Well, got to go tap into some ancient wisdom.
And standing on my fingers is really starting to hurt.
Leslie Bow, professor of English and Asian American Studies at the University of Wisconsin at Madison, is the author of the recently published “Partly Colored: Asian Americans and Racial Anomaly in the Segregated South” (NYU Press). She can be reached at pmproj [at] progressive [dot] org.
- Login or register to post comments
- Printer-friendly version
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
This form needs Javascript to display, which your browser doesn't support. Sign up here instead
|
CURRENT ISSUE: JUNE 2012
Cecile Richards
Ruth Conniff | "Millions of women are counting on us for care. And if we're gone, there's no one else there," says the head of Planned Parenthood.
What's at Stake in Wisconsin
Ruth Conniff and Matthew Rothschild | Much more than Scott Walker's future hangs in the balance.
The Mother of Midwifery
Eleanor J. Bader | Ina May Gaskin has delivered more than 1,200 babies and revolutionized the field.
Scott Walker, the Monster.
See more at http://www.zinasaunders.com -- On June 5th, the voters of Wisconsin will decide whether to recall Scott Walker, the monster created by an unholy alliance between the radical right and big business, who has made attacking unions the hallmark of his administration. Cover for The Progressive magazine June 2012: http://www.progressive.org
Come to Progressive Talks and Events
June 4, Madison, WI
Terry Tempest Williams on "The Power of Voice"
Ruth Conniff and Matthew Rothschild on
"What's at Stake in the Recall."
5:30-7:30 pm at the Lakeside St. Coffee House, 402 W. Lakeside St, Madison.
It's a fundraiser for The Progressive. Contributions are tax-deductible.
If you can't make it but would like to contribute anyway, please send your check to The Progressive, 409 E. Main St., Madison, WI 53703.












Comments
Cheap MBT Shoes online Hurricane Earl is expected to gain more strength before heading towards the US MBT Shoes,Forecasters say it is Mbt Sport Shoes a major hurricane and could cause "catastrophic"Cheap Mbt Chapa Shoes damage if it hits land.Strong winds and heavy rains are already lashing several islands in Caribbean,but Buy Mbt Tariki the storm has now passed by the Virgin Islands Black Mbt Fanaka Shoes .The hurricane is generating sustained winds of 215km/h (135mph). It is Mbt M Walk Shoes currently north-east of MBT Imara Black Shoes Puerto Rico, and moving west-northwest at about 24km/h, the US-based National Hurricane Center (NHC) Womens MBT Kaya Shoes reports.The centre of the storm is MBT Unono Black Shoes expected to move away Womens MBT Lami Shoes from the Virgin Islands on Monday night and pass to the east of the Turks and Caicos on Tuesday night.Discount Mbt Shuguli Gtx Hurricane warnings in place on several islands in the region have now been degraded.However, Earl caused heavy rains MBT Karani Shoes and Womens MBT Sapatu Shoes flooding in low-lying areas, and it damaged homes on several islands including Antigua and Barbuda.Several MBT Safiri Shoes Online countries reported power outages.Womens MBT Tunisha Shoes Cruise ships were diverted and flights cancelled across the region.The NHC said Womens MBT Voi Shoes it was too early to say what effect Mens MBT Fora Shoes Earl would have on the eastern US coast later in the week, but it warned coastal residents from MBT Tembea Shoes On Sale North Carolina to Maine to watch the storm's path.Earl is being closely followed by Tropical Storm Fiona, currently east of the Discount MBT Fuaba Shoes Leeward Isles with winds of up to 65km/h