Obama Leaves Bush-Cheney Repressive Apparatus Standing

By Matthew Rothschild, September 21, 2009

Civil libertarians cheered the election of Barack Obama, and with good reason.

Bush and Cheney had trampled all over our rights and liberties.

And as someone who taught constitutional law, Obama denounced the Presidential power grabs and pledged to address them.

But he hasn’t followed through on that pledge.

This week, the Senate is holding a hearing on the reauthorization of some expiring—and troubling--sections of the Patriot Act. The Obama Administration wants to reauthorize them nonetheless.

One of these is Section 215, which allows the FBI to slap National Security Letters on bookstores and libraries and thereby find out who has been checking out or buying which book. This is a violation of our right to privacy and to Free Speech, and Obama should know better.

Obama’s Administration is also making the outrageous claim that it can detain anyone it wants at Bagram Air Force Base in Afghanistan, and then deny that person all access to due process and habeas corpus.

Nor has Obama made any move to rectify the blatant denial of due process that is embedded in the Military Commissions Act, which allows the President to designate anyone an enemy combatant and jail you. If you’re not a U.S. citizen, he can jail you as an “alien enemy combatant,” and you may never see a judge or a lawyer for the rest of your life.

Nor has Obama withdrawn National Security Presidential Directive 51, which gives to the President extraordinary powers over the other branches of government at every level in times of an emergency that he himself declares.

These examples strongly suggest that Obama doesn’t have the will to tear down the edifice of oppression that Bush and Cheney constructed.

As a result, we remain today a much less free country than we were eight years ago. And it looks like we’ll remain that way tomorrow.

Even if Obama doesn’t use these powers against us, a rightwing successor like Sarah Palin sure might.

This is one issue where libertarians and progressive need to get together on, in a hurry.

Comments

The Blind Left Eye, Again.

Here is useful idiocy at its best.

"Even if Obama doesn’t use these powers against us, a rightwing successor like Sarah Palin sure might."

Sure. Sarah Palin is the one INVITING citizens to forward email messages to her that seem fishy, even private ones, right? Even while criticizing Obama on civil liberties grounds, you cannot help yourself inventing even worse "rightwing" depradations so as to prove to your nervous foundation-running radical brats and others on the left that you always know how to keep to the central historical task, the demonization of conservatives.

I for one am happy Obama is keeping these reasonable safeguards against murderous attacks on the homeland. I hope these, and not his pretend show trials for CIA operatives, reflect his true priorities. I do fear his totalitarian leanings. But these manifest themselves in ways your magazine has failed utterly to note or critique, so why should I bother doing it for you.

Submitted by JonBurack on Mon, 09/21/2009 - 7:41pm.

CURRENT ISSUE: FEBRUARY 2012

February 2012

Progressive Matt

The Koch Brothers Conspire to Buy the White House