Zakaria’s Capitalist Apologia

By Matthew Rothschild, June 17, 2009

Fareed Zakaria takes to the cover of Newsweek this week to pass out his “Capitalist Manifesto.”

It’s not exactly stirring reading, unlike that other manifesto.

Few apologias are.

And that’s what this one is for the current crisis of capitalism: a big blanket of “Oh, it’s not so bad.”

Says Zakaria: “A few years from now, strange as it may sound, we might all find that we are hungry for more capitalism, not less.”

Here’s his argument.

First, he says, “When countries need growth, they turn to markets.” But not when the markets have capitulated, as they have now, and as they did in the 1930. In such circumstances, it’s much more prudent to turn to government for growth.

Then he piles on some “ifs” to arrive at the “then” that he prefers.

Hold on while I quote him:

“If, in the years ahead, the American consumer remains reluctant to spend,

if federal and state governments groan under their debt,

if government-owned companies remain expensive burdens,

then private sector activity will become the only path to create jobs.”

Well, he boiled the alternative right off that sentence.

And that alternative is federal deficit spending to create jobs and alleviate state budget crunches.

Having performed this sleight of hand, he all but says voila and then concludes: “capitalism remains the most productive economic engine we have yet invented.”

But the engine isn’t working right now. And it’s something serious, despite Zakaria’s sophistry.

His remedy for that is archaic and disproven: “We can ask that people steer themselves and their institutions with a greater reliance on a moral compass.”

Alan Greenspan has already pleaded guilty to believing in this myth that capitalists will be able to self-regulate.

But now Zakaria gives the myth another spin.

Comments

The US had a Capitalist bubble after WWII--thats it folks. It doesnt work.

Regulated Socialistic Capitalism, maybe. But, I suspect "Lone Wolf Merkins" would rather die than pay taxes so that their fellow citizens doint die in the street. Problem is, the ones in the street are the ones who die.

"Clean tap water" is a "free mkt" commodity? Not here! They tried it in Latin America and they decided thayd rather have Socialism.

"Private medical insurance"--yeah, thats working out real well...but youre right about one thing--the 'Merkin people are always stuopid enough to fall for "tax cuts for the rich?"--they all "want to be a Millionaire"--but it never happens. You can watch it on tv.

The "welfare state" has been gone since Clinton, Wall St brought down the eocnomy, because free mkt capitalism doesnt work.

THE US will figure it out, too late, as always.

Submitted by KDelphi on Wed, 06/24/2009 - 10:50pm.

CURRENT ISSUE: FEBRUARY 2012

February 2012

Progressive Matt

The Koch Brothers Conspire to Buy the White House