Jerry Lewis doesn’t deserve a humanitarian award at the Oscars

By Mike Ervin, February 19, 2009

The Oscars are about to insult people with disabilities.

At the Academy Awards ceremony Feb. 22, the board of governors of the Academy of Motion Picture Arts & Sciences will present its Jean Hersholt Humanitarian Award to Jerry Lewis.

Lewis is notorious for making disparaging remarks about others, particularly gay people and women.

But he has said equally degrading things about people with disabilities.

For decades, disability rights activists have criticized how his annual telethon for the Muscular Dystrophy Association exploits people with disabilities by making us into objects of pity.

To this, Lewis responded in 2001, “You don’t want to be pitied because you’re a cripple in a wheelchair, stay in your house!”

Lewis becomes particularly enraged when those who protest against his telethon and him are people with muscular dystrophy — like me.

In a 1993 article in Vanity Fair magazine, he said about me, “This one kid in Chicago would have passed through this life and never had the opportunity to be acknowledged by anybody, but he found out that by being a dissident he gets picked up in a limo by a television station.”

The damage Lewis has done to the disability community goes far beyond name-calling. He and his telethon symbolize an antiquated and destructive 1950s charity mentality.

This says that people with disabilities have no hope and nothing to offer unless we are cured, so the whole focus should be raising money for behemoth charities that can find that cure.

This is a dangerously simplistic outlook.

It devalues and dehumanizes people with disabilities by suggesting we can be worthy contributors only if we first shed our disabilities.

It gives people permission to avoid addressing the daunting task of creating an inclusive society if they simply make an annual contribution to Jerry.

Disability rights activists still fight daily to shatter the barriers that exclude and segregate people with disabilities. Those barriers are rooted in the outmoded charity mentality.

Lewis and his telethon are the primary force that perpetuates that mentality.

By giving Lewis this honor, the board of governors of the Academy shows that its view of people with disabilities and our potential has not evolved in 50 years.

Mike Ervin is a Chicago-based writer and a disability-rights activist with ADAPT (www.adapt.org). He can be reached at pmproj [at] progressive [dot] org.

Comments

When Lewis first began the "Jerry's Kids" ripoff it was clear to anyone who understands the business of charitable donations that he was receiving too big a piece of the pie for the charity he was serving. Muscular Dystrophy is not a condition per se, but is instead a collection of genetic diseases which are, essentially, incurable after they present. This is to say that the only "cure" (and it would actually have to be cures for the myriad of genetic formulae it represents) would have to come about prior to birth. Otherwise, the sufferer has been born with the condition and, medicine in the foreseeable future is at a loss to do much about it other than aid and comfort. The number of persons who suffer from this condition in the general population is not a large number compared to other humanitarian enterprises, e.g., various cancers, HIV, Hepatitis B & C, lung diseases, poverty, human rights initiatives, etc. Hence, Lewis's endeavor garners entirely too much of the available total, voluntary contributions for the size of the population it serves. This takes monies away from breast cancer, homelessness, HIV studies, and all of the other combined charities clambering for resources. Jerry Lewis is an unfair player in a very restricted field and everyone is afraid to speak out. Celebrities have a way of reaching in the bag and picking a favorite charity for which to become the spokesperson. Lewis did precisely this, but when his career waned after the breakup with Dean Martin, he literally hitched his wagon to the back end of the charity and began the damnable telethons in order to keep his celebrity alive. He's an opportunistic jerk.

Submitted by Dick Hudson on Fri, 02/20/2009 - 4:10pm.

CURRENT ISSUE: FEBRUARY 2012

February 2012

Progressive Matt

The Koch Brothers Conspire to Buy the White House