If we are to err as Americans on any side in our critique of other countries, it should be in the direction of being...
By Bill Lann Lee and Christopher Punongbayan
On the fiftieth anniversary of the 1964 Civil Rights Act, let’s remember that it protected not just African Americans. The legislation, enacted by Congress on July 2 of that year, broadly outlawed discrimination on the basis of race, color, and national origin.
This was altogether fitting and proper, for racial prejudice extended beyond the brutality of slavery and Jim Crow that African Americans experienced.
Asian Americans, for instance, have also suffered.
In the late nineteenth century, Chinese Americans in California and elsewhere in the West faced discrimination in the workplace and the schools and the housing market. And they often had to fend off racist attacks.
Japanese and Filipino immigrants endured similar maltreatment upon their arrival.
And during World War II, President Roosevelt incarcerated over 120,000 Japanese Americans in internment camps although they posed no national security threat.
Shortly after 9/11, South Asian Americans, Arab Americans and Muslim Americans became fused together as public enemy number one and faced unprecedented levels of deportation and surveillance, as well as discrimination and violence in the workplace, schools and even their own homes.
Today, Asian Americans, with a population of more than18 million, still face stereotypes and are under suspicion as national security risks.
And the doors aren’t as open as they used to be.
In the 1960s, Asian Americans made huge strides in admissions to the University of California, for instance, after they were included in affirmative action plans. While many Asian Americans can now attend college without the help of affirmative action programs, others cannot. For many African American, Latino and Southeast Asian students, including Cambodians, Filipinos, Vietnamese, Hmong and Laotians, the hope of going to college is more distant than ever.
The job market is also biased. Once hired, Asian Americans often bump up against the glass ceiling in promotions. Nationally, Asian Americans have greater educational attainment — including graduate and professional degrees — but lower per capita income and fewer managerial jobs than whites with the same education. Asian Americans are often stereotyped as hard workers but not leadership material or aggressive enough to be managers and entrepreneurs.
Communities of color have borne the brunt of racial inequalities meted out by our immigration system. The notorious Chinese Exclusion Act is gone, but the Immigration Reform and Control Act bars immigrants from working without authorization.
Today, there are 1 million undocumented Asian Americans who cannot legally work. A quarter million of the 2 million individuals deported since 2008 were immigrants of Asian descent.
Our civil rights protections provide no remedy for discriminatory immigration laws. We must modernize our civil rights protections to prevent racial discrimination in our immigration system.
Fifty years after the Civil Rights Act, Asian Americans, like other minorities, have much to celebrate, but not yet true equal justice under law. All Americans of goodwill should keep striving for that goal.
Bill Lann Lee is the former Assistant Attorney General for Civil Rights in the U.S. Department of Justice. Christopher Punongbayan is the Executive Director of Advancing Justice – Asian Law Caucus.