Mexican drug war losing proposition for all of us

By Miguel Tinker Salas, April 1, 2010

Egged on by the United States, Mexico is waging an ill-conceived war on drugs that has led to an explosion of violence.

On March 27, 10 young people between the ages of 8 and 21 were gunned down in the state of Durango.

Just two weeks earlier, on March 13, three U.S. consular employees were murdered in Ciudad Juarez, across the border from El Paso, Texas.

On Jan. 31, 15 teenagers at a party in Ciudad Juarez were murdered by drug dealers.

These are just a few of the incidents. The drug violence killed 2,600 people last year in Ciudad Juarez, and has taken a toll of 600 already this year.

Subscribe to The Progressive

More than 19,000 Mexicans have died in this failed war, almost four times as many casualties as the United States has suffered in the Iraq and Afghanistan wars combined.

Shortly after narrowly winning a controversial election in 2006, Mexican President Felipe Calderon launched his war on the drug cartels. But over the past decades, the drug mafias have penetrated every aspect of Mexican society, gaining influence in the political and social arena, controlling municipal, state and even federal police forces.

As the government invested less and less on the social front, drug lords such as Joaquin (el Chapo) Guzman and Osiel Cardenas started to give generously to the poor, thereby achieving Robin Hood-like status. Their actions even spawned “narcocorrido,” a musical genre that celebrates their exploits. And much to the chagrin of the Calderon administration, for two years running Guzman has been listed on the Forbes billionaire list.

Drug cartels have evolved from local gangs into transnational enterprises with intricate power structures that reach into every corner of Mexico and beyond. The drug cartels represent a state within a state, controlling vast swaths of territory with significant social and military resources at their disposal.

With full U.S. support, Calderon has mistakenly relied on a military strategy, deploying the army to key battleground states such as Chihuahua, Michoacan, Baja California and Tamaulipas. The cartels regroup and initiate operations elsewhere so that increasingly all of Mexico feels the pain of this expanding conflict.

Calderon’s strategy of relying on the military exposes it to the same factors that have corrupted the Mexican police force. As a possible sign that the cartels have made inroads in the military, in recent months, Calderon has increasingly relied on the navy to carry out operations.

As the government prosecutes the war on the cartels, many Mexicans see their conditions worsen. A World Bank report underscored the social cost of Calderon’s policies: Between 2006 and 2008, 5.9 million Mexicans joined the ranks of the poor, and since then their numbers have swelled by another 4.2 million. In total, 51 percent of the Mexican population lives in poverty.

The drug war will not be won on the battlefield. Instead, the government must adopt a multipronged approach that grapples with social inequality, directs investments to rebuild the devastated countryside and engages in a dialogue with social and civic organizations to develop a national approach aimed at curtailing the influence of the drug traffickers.

Likewise, the United States cannot continue to be the largest market for illegal drugs in the world, and it must move beyond empty phrases such as “shared responsibility” that are intended as sound bites and carry no policy implications. Absent a comprehensive binational approach, the war will continue to rage in Mexico.

Calderon will be out of office in three years, but unfortunately the legacy he has bequeathed Mexico will continue long after he has retired.

Miguel Tinker Salas is a professor of history and Latin American studies at Pomona College in Claremont, Calif., and the author and editor of a number of books on Latin America. He can be reached at pmproj [at] progressive [dot] org.

Comments

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Lagvvk ovmabnrngrli, by Anonymous
Xn580i nejatoehupll, by Anonymous
AGArcX olykaqrugprd, by Anonymous
YDEl2x yzqgoomtkshr, by Anonymous
UIVXDy chbovnyfpgez, by Anonymous
TkTEj4 khxepsiolqto, by Anonymous
lfVDeM iluzdeffuuef, by Anonymous
The Progressive facebook page The Progressive twitter page The Progressive RSS The Progressive Daily Radio The Progressive Weekly Radio

ELECTION 2012 BLOG

Not everyone is voting in the Wisconsin recall election

Despite estimates this week that turnout for the June 5 recall election could top 60%, there are some Madisonians who do not plan to vote.

Latest Barrett poll has Walker up 50-48

The Wisconsin recall race is a "dead heat," says the Barrett campaign, which released the findings of a poll it conducted May 29 and 30, four days later than the Marquette poll. The campaign's poll showed Walker up 50-48 over Barrett. The poll was of 821 likely voters and had a margin of error +3.5%. The Barrett campaign says the poll also indicated that the John Doe scandal was hurting Walker. It also noted that "Barrett leads Walker 56-42 among people who did not vote in 2010," so "turnout is key."

Join comedians Chris Lay and Alan Talaga for a Wisconsin recall debate live blog Thursday night

Two of Madison's sharpest political minds, stand-up comedians Chris Lay (@MrChrisLay) and Alan Talaga (@danpotacke), will provide the blow-by-blow analysis right here on Thursday night at 9 p.m. (CDT) during the second of two debates between Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker and Milwaukee Mayor Tom Barrett in advance of the historic recall election on June 5. The debate will be televised in Madison on WKOW, Channel 27, and we urge you to keep at least one eye on this blog while you watch it.

Citizen Dave: If the Milwaukee DA has anything on Walker, he should charge him now

Governor Scott Walker is now paying $160,000 for nothing. The governor has said repeatedly that he is not the target of a John Doe investigation in Milwaukee County, yet his campaign has transferred another $100,000 to his legal defense fund, bringing the total amount dedicated to defend him against nothing to $160,000.

Feingold Revs Up Crowd for Barrett

“I’ve never met a more decent person in or out of politics.” Former Sen. Russ Feingold revved up a crowd at a fundraiser for Tom Barrett on Wednesday night in the recall battle against Gov. Scott Walker.
A partnership between Isthmus and The Progressive featuring news, analysis and commentary on Wisconsin politics, from the historic recall through the general election in November. All Posts >>

CURRENT ISSUE: JUNE 2012

June 2012

The ED Show - Bill Clinton heads to Wisconsin to campaign against Walker.