Obama's FISA Betrayal

By Matthew Rothschild, June 24, 2008

Barack Obama’s rightward sprint is nowhere more obvious than in his betrayal on the FISA bill.

This bill allows the President to grab all incoming and outgoing international communications without a warrant.

The ACLU says it represents “an unprecedented extension of governmental surveillance over Americans.”

Obama, sounding on Friday a lot like Bush, said: “Given the legitimate threats we face, providing effective intelligence collection tools with appropriate safeguards is too important to delay.”

Here’s what Bush said the same day as Obama: The bill “allows our intelligence professionals to quickly and effectively monitor the plans of terrorists abroad, while protecting the liberties of Americans here at home.”

But it doesn’t protect our liberties, and Obama ought to know that.

Obama said it “firmly reestablishes basic judicial oversight over all domestic surveillance.”

But the ACLU notes that the bill “permits only minimal court oversight. The FISA Court only reviews general procedures for targeting and minimizing the use of information that is collected. The court may not know who, what, or where will actually be tapped, thereby undercutting any meaningful for the court and violating the Fourth Amendment.”

What’s more, in the incredibly rare instances where the FISA Court denies a warrant to the President, under the new bill the President can go ahead and do the wiretapping anyway while the appeals process continues, a process that the ACLU says can take two months.

Russ Feingold calls the idea that this is a good compromise “a farce” and “political cover.”

Says Feingold: “Anybody who claims this is an OK bill, I really question if they’ve even read it.”

Has Obama?

If not, that’s a problem.

And if he has, and still approves of it, that’s an even bigger one.

Please log into Facebook to post comments.
The Progressive facebook page The Progressive twitter page The Progressive Weekly Radio The Progressive Daily Radio The Progressive Weekly Radio

CURRENT ISSUE: June 2013

June 2013

Preserving Our Home on Earth

We’ve released our second eBook  from a new “Hidden History e-book series: monthly installments  of  riveting selections from our  archives.

Preserving Our Home on  Earth: 100 Years of Environmental  Writing from the Archives of The  Progressive Magazine. is now  available from Amazon and Barnes&Noble.

"Since we only have one planet to call our own, it might be worth reading this book." —Bill McKibben



Welcome to The Progressive Magazine