Time to fix the safety net
We need to repair our nation’s safety net.
Back in 1996, President Clinton and Congress ended “welfare as we know it” and substituted it with TANF, Temporary Aid for Needy Families.
They pushed TANF through in the middle of an economic expansion. Today, we’re in the midst of a severe recession, with double-digit unemployment rates afflicting blacks and likely to soon afflict the overall population.
In this context, it’s hard to justify the five-year limit on aid that the TANF law imposes. States may elect to provide families aid for more than the cumulative 60 months, but the federal government limits the number of families who can be helped, and penalizes states if they offer too much aid.
Before TANF, welfare recipients could also attend college to improve their skills before returning to the labor market. TANF limited college attendance and reduced vocational training to one year.
These TANF provisions don’t seem realistic in the face of this recession, either.
Congress reauthorized TANF in 2005, but the legislators kept its funding flat it through 2010. This means we have a pre-recession level of assistance available in a recessionary time. That won’t do.
People who found jobs before exhausting their 60 months of eligibility may have only a few months left, even as they are now losing their jobs. Others, who might ordinarily enter the labor market, have nowhere to turn for a job and have nothing to fall back on. Still others, who need public assistance, and qualify for it, may not get it because the states don’t have the money to distribute it.
In the middle of an economic expansion, it was easy for our legislators to engage in a moral argument about public assistance. Some portrayed welfare recipients in the most contemptuous terms, as lazy and morally inferior. Rep. E. Clay Shaw Jr., R-Fla., said they were people “you wouldn’t leave your cat with.”
Today’s recession mocks such scorn. Millions of people need aid out of no fault of their own. The economy has simply stopped working.
If numbers are the only measure, TANF was a stunning success, with the number of families on aid dropping for 10.3 million in 1997 to 4.3 million in 2006.
But the numbers don’t tell all. They don’t tell what happened to these people who fell off the rolls. They don’t explain the invisible challenges that people faced because of the limitations of TANF. And they don’t take into consideration what will happen to people in times like these, when jobs are not available.
Today, even the most callous legislator would have a hard time making a moral argument against poor people, or those who have lost their jobs because our economy is tottering on the brink of disaster. Instead, we might explore the immorality of the Madoffs of the world (people you could not leave your cash with).
The safety net we shredded more than 12 years ago would come in handy today as we deal with this recession. Without it, hundreds of thousands of families face hunger, hardship and homelessness.
They not only need a safety net. They deserve one.
Julianne Malveaux is president of Bennett College for Women in Greensboro, N.C. She can be reached at pmproj [at] progressive [dot] org.
Tags:
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
This form needs Javascript to display, which your browser doesn't support. Sign up here instead
|
CURRENT ISSUE: JUNE 2012
Cecile Richards
Ruth Conniff | "Millions of women are counting on us for care. And if we're gone, there's no one else there," says the head of Planned Parenthood.
What's at Stake in Wisconsin
Ruth Conniff and Matthew Rothschild | Much more than Scott Walker's future hangs in the balance.
The Mother of Midwifery
Eleanor J. Bader | Ina May Gaskin has delivered more than 1,200 babies and revolutionized the field.
Ed Show: Walker's Economy Worst In The Nation
Come to Progressive Talks and Events
June 4, Madison, WI
Terry Tempest Williams on "The Power of Voice"
Ruth Conniff and Matthew Rothschild on
"What's at Stake in the Recall."
5:30-7:30 pm at the Lakeside St. Coffee House, 402 W. Lakeside St, Madison.
It's a fundraiser for The Progressive. Contributions are tax-deductible.
If you can't make it but would like to contribute anyway, please send your check to The Progressive, 409 E. Main St., Madison, WI 53703.









