Why “Slumdog Millionaire” didn’t deserve its awards

Like others before it, this was a voyeuristic look at the Third World’s poor and vulnerable. There was no sense of history, no glimpse of peoples’ struggles and really no dignity.
The big screen shuffled its images in a vacuum.
I’ve seen quite a bit of slums, poverty and destitution in my life.
I’ve even seen how an open-air, wood-platform, makeshift toilet seat actually works. I have a feeling none of the moviemakers experienced the thick of it, though it plays a comic part in the film.
But the comedy doesn’t work because it’s grotesque, as is much of the film: filled with violence, horror, lies and distortions.
For instance, the handsome movie superstar would never get off his helicopter and sign an autograph for a feces-smeared poor kid who somehow rubbed past the throngs of the adoring crowd. No way — it’s a lie. And that’s why it’s really horrible.
Yes, it’s OK to show poverty, show disparity. That’s fine, even more than fine. But show it in a real way. Don’t leave its causes unexplored. Don’t raise false hope.
And yes, it’s fine to show a communal riot scene. Of course, Hindu fascists in Mumbai slaughtered Muslim slum dwellers after riots broke out when Hindu nationalists destroyed the Babri mosque in 1992.
But few Western viewers, and few of the Hollywood elite who get to vote for the Oscars, had any clue about the barbarity they were witnessing. Out of nowhere, the protagonist’s mom and neighbors are rounded up and butchered. Riots in India don’t quite happen that way.
The incomprehensibility of the film reaches its apex in the “ Who Wants to Be a Millionaire” game itself. Take one example: An American tourist couple visits the Taj Mahal and to display their generosity, they give the protagonist a $100 bill for a tip, and this helps him to learn which American figure is printed on the money — an answer he needs to keep going in the contest. Talk about preposterous!
I feel sorry for the young performers who poured their hearts out on and off camera, and were not properly compensated for their work.
I feel even sorrier for the young-generation Bollywood patriots who crave to see India honored on the Oscar stage — at any cost.
“Slumdog Millionaire” failed them all.
Partha Banerjee is a New York-based media and immigrant rights activist. He teaches at Empire State College. He can be reached at pmproj [at] progressive [dot] org.
- Login or register to post comments
- Printer-friendly version
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
This form needs Javascript to display, which your browser doesn't support. Sign up here instead
|
Resist Censorship in Tucson
- Banned in Tucson
- An Interview with Carlos Muñoz on the Tucson Book Ban
| Banned Authors Respond | |
CURRENT ISSUE: FEBRUARY 2012
Inside the Occupy Movement
Arun Gupta and Michelle Fawcett | We visited nearly thirty occupations in twenty states in two months.
What I got at Occupy Wall Street
Breanna Lembitz | I spent seven weeks in Zuccotti Park, and here is what I got.
Danny Glover
Ed Rampell | The Progressive Interview | March 2012 issue
To Wed or Not to Wed
Stephanie Fairyington | March 2012 issue
Progressive Matt
The Koch Brothers Conspire to Buy the White House
Ruth Conniff at the People's Legislature in Madison
Standing for Justice at the Capitol. Matthew Rothschild.
Come to Progressive Talks and Events
Feb. 18, 5:30 p.m.
Ruth Conniff, Progressive Principles Conference at Yale University 11-1
Read more >>
Thursday February 16 at 7:30 p.m.
VandeBurg Room, Pyle Center. Madison, WI
Not Just Gandhi: The Tradition of Nonviolence Among Muslims in South Asia
Amitabh Pal Managing Editor, The Progressive magazine.
Read more >>
Friday February 17 at 7:30 p.m. Kate Clinton at the Barrymore with Michael Feldman in Madison.
Thursday February 23 at 3:30 p.m.
Garden Key Room, Student Union, University of Central Florida, Orlando, Florida
Islam Means Peace: Understanding the Muslim Principle of Nonviolence Today
Amitabh Pal Managing Editor, The Progressive magazine.
Read more >>








Comments