Bob Peterson
The recent spate of book bannings in the Tucson, Arizona should be a wake up call for all who care about multicultural education and academic freedom in our schools.
The list of banned books range from Howard Zinn's People's History of the United States to Rethinking Columbus, published here in Milwaukee by Rethinking Schools. The bannings stem from an Arizona law passed last year that, among other things, banned ethnic studies programs in K-12 schools.
The banned books, according to a district spokesperson quoted Jan. 13, [highlight salon blog] will be "cleared from all classrooms, boxed up and sent to the Textbook Depository for storage." One on-the-scene report indicated "banned books were seized from [students'] classrooms and out of their hands."
I personally have never had one of my books banned before. I guess it's a badge of honor. But it's a badge no one in this country should want to wear.
What's most disturbing is the banning's broader context, in particular Arizona's anti-immigrant legislation and the move across the country toward scripted curriculum that too often ignores students' cultural heritages and that undermines the ability to promote critical thinking. On a more positive note, however, the banning can be seen as the flailing of small-minded bigots attempting to derail multicultural, anti-racist curriculum. In this sense, the move is similar to the anti-gay rantings of Santorum and Company.
The Tucson banning is a an outgrowth of an Arizona law passed last year that bans k-12 schools from teaching anything that may be interpreted as promoting the overthrow of the U.S. government or resentment toward a race or class of people. The ban also prohibits courses that are designed primarily for pupils of one ethnic group, or that advocate ethnic solidarity.
This has led to the termination of Mexican American literature courses and the banning of several books.
Information on the list of banned books is still unfolding —it's not something the school district is making public. However, a blog by Nambe Pueblo writer Debbie Reese listed several books. They range from Sherman Alexie's Ten Little Indians and Tonto and the Lone Ranger Fist Fight in Heaven, to Jonathan Kozol's Savage Inequalities.
Ethnic studies programs have shown to have positive impact on students. This was the conclusion by scholar Christine Sleeter in her recent study, The Academic and Social Value of Ethnic Studies. She states, "There is considerable research evidence that well designed and well-taught ethnic studies curricula have positive academic and social outcomes for students."
Specific data in Tucson confirm these findings. According to a Tucson Unified School District report issued March 11, 2011, TUSD's Mexican American Studies program give students a measurable advantage over non-MAS students in passing standardized AIMS reading and writing tests, and that MAS students graduate at higher levels than their non MAS counterparts."
Educators should demand that Arizona officials lift their prohibition of ethnic studies classes and cease their book banning. We should also examine our own curricula, textbooks and student learning objectives to see if we are adequately addressing issues of our community's cultural diversity, the history of racism and struggle against its current forms.
Ironically, the Arizona book banning comes at the time when many people are celebrating the birthday of Martin Luther King, Jr.
These developments in Arizona remind us all that much work is to be done – in Arizona and in our own communities – before we realize King's dream.
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
This form needs Javascript to display, which your browser doesn't support. Sign up here instead
|
CURRENT ISSUE: MAY 2012
Lizz Winstead
By Elizabeth DiNovella | “The media was supposed to be the watchdog for the regular folks, and now comedians have to be the watchdog of the media,” says the creator of The Daily Show.
On the Trail with Elizabeth Warren
Abby Scher | “The banks broke this economy one lousy mortgage at time,” says the populist Senate candidate.
June issue | What’s at Stake in Wisconsin
By Ruth Conniff and Matthew Rothschild | After a year and a half of historic protests and unprecedented citizen activism, the recall is a referendum on whether grassroots, democratic action can overcome the power of money in the Citizens United era.
Ed Show: Walker's Economy Worst In The Nation
Come to Progressive Talks and Events
June 4, Madison, WI
Terry Tempest Williams on "The Power of Voice"
Ruth Conniff and Matthew Rothschild on
"What's at Stake in the Recall."
5:30-7:30 pm at the Lakeside St. Coffee House, 402 W. Lakeside St, Madison.
It's a fundraiser for The Progressive. Contributions are tax-deductible.
If you can't make it but would like to contribute anyway, please send your check to The Progressive, 409 E. Main St., Madison, WI 53703.









